Build vs Buy: When to Use Off-the-Shelf Tools
Every data decision involves a choice: build a custom solution or buy an existing tool? The right answer depends on your specific situation, and getting it wrong is expensive.
The Tradeoffs
Buying (SaaS, off-the-shelf tools): - Fast to implement - Vendor handles maintenance and updates - Proven at scale - Limited customization - Ongoing subscription costs - Vendor lock-in risk
Building (custom development): - Fits exact requirements - Full control over features and roadmap - No per-seat licensing - Requires development resources - You own maintenance forever - Takes longer to ship
Neither is inherently better. The right choice depends on context.
When to Buy
The problem is generic. Sending emails, processing payments, tracking time, managing projects - thousands of companies have the same need. Someone already built a good solution.
Speed matters more than customization. You need something working next week, not next quarter. A good-enough tool today beats a perfect tool in six months.
You lack development resources. Building requires developers. If you don't have them (or they're busy), buying is the only realistic option.
The vendor is more expert than you'll ever be. Stripe knows more about payments than you ever will. Auth0 knows more about authentication. Leverage their expertise.
Maintenance burden would be high. That simple thing you built becomes a complex system to maintain. Vendors handle that for you.
When to Build
The problem is core to your business. If data processing IS your product, building makes sense. If it's supporting infrastructure, probably not.
No existing tool fits. You've genuinely looked, and nothing comes close. (Be honest - have you really looked?)
You need deep integration. When the solution needs to be tightly woven into your systems in ways no API supports.
Scale economics favor it. At massive scale, custom solutions can be cheaper than per-seat or per-transaction licensing.
You have the team. Building requires developers who understand the problem. Don't underestimate this.
The Middle Ground
Build on top of platforms. Use Snowflake as your warehouse (buy), but build custom dbt models (build). Use Salesforce (buy), but build custom integrations (build).
Buy now, build later. Start with a tool to learn what you actually need. Build custom only after you deeply understand the problem.
Customize within limits. Most SaaS tools allow some customization. Exhaust those options before building from scratch.
Common Mistakes
Underestimating maintenance. Building something takes X months. Maintaining it takes forever. Factor in the ongoing cost.
Not-invented-here syndrome. Engineering teams often want to build. Sometimes that's ego, not strategy. Challenge the assumption.
Buying without evaluating. Choosing the first tool you find. Competition exists for a reason - evaluate options.
Over-customizing purchased tools. Modifying a SaaS tool so heavily that you can't upgrade. You've built a Frankenstein.
Ignoring hidden costs of buying. Subscription fees are obvious. Implementation, training, integration, and migration costs are often not.
Evaluating a Buy Decision
Questions to ask: 1. Does it solve the core problem? (Not just nice-to-have features) 2. Can it integrate with our existing systems? 3. What's the total cost? (Licensing + implementation + training + integration) 4. What's the exit cost if we need to switch later? 5. How's the vendor's track record? Will they be around in 5 years? 6. What do current customers say?
Evaluating a Build Decision
Questions to ask: 1. Do we have the right skills on the team? 2. How long will it take? (Then double that estimate) 3. What's the ongoing maintenance burden? 4. Is this the best use of our engineering time? 5. What's our competitive advantage from building this? 6. What happens when key developers leave?
The Data Stack Specifically
For most companies building a modern data stack:
Buy: Cloud data warehouse (Snowflake, BigQuery), ETL connectors (Fivetran), BI tools (Looker, Tableau)
Build: Custom transformation logic (dbt models), data quality rules specific to your business, integrations to proprietary systems
Evaluate carefully: ML platforms, data catalogs, workflow orchestration - depends on complexity and requirements
The Right Mindset
Think of it as a portfolio. Some things you buy. Some things you build. The goal is making good decisions about each component, not ideological commitment to one approach.
This decision affects your whole data stack. Learn about data stack components and whether you need an ETL tool.
---
Sources: - McKinsey: Build, Buy, or Partner - HBR: Build, Buy, or Ally - Gartner: Build vs Buy Framework